http://worldwidehelp.blogspot.com
we, the media
 

"Inflaming communal passions"

Naresh Fernandes, Editor, Time Out, is unhappy about the recent arrest of a TOI reporter for "deliberately injuring religious sentiments." He'd like to get a discussion going on the matter. Here's his letter.

Dear Editor,

I’d like to call the attention of your readers to a cynical attempt by political workers to inflame religious passions in Mumbai over the last week, harnessing the eager assistance of the authorities to turn the press into the scapegoat.

The chain of events went into play with the publication of a report on Feb 19 in the Times of India, detailing the arrest of one of its reporters under 295A of the IPC (deliberately injuring religious sentiments). The article says that the reporter, whom it does not identify, was arrested on the complaint of a local municipal corporator, who claimed to have taken offence at an article written one month ago about pets owned by Bollywood stars. It goes on to state that the arrest was carried out even though the paper had already apologised for details in the article that were later found to be inaccurate  the very details to which the complainant had taken offence.

A subsequent report in Mid-Day on Feb 21 casts more light on the episode. Though the Mid-Day report makes no mention of the arrest of the Times reporter, it says that the actress Manisha Koirala has been provided police protection “after her dog’s name sparked protests among Muslim fundamentalists.” The report says that “members of the community lodged a complaint at Versova police station saying that the dog’s name, Mustafa, was same as that of their spiritual head and had to be withdrawn immediately.”

While the Times management has forbidden the reporter from speaking to the press about the incident, her colleagues have identified her as Meena Iyer, a reporter on the Bollywood beat. They say that she was arrested by the plain-clothes policemen, who appeared at her home at 9 on the morning of Feb 18. At first, they even refused her permission to change out of her night-clothes and they jostled her, her colleagues say.

The episode raises troubling questions. To start with, since the report was published a month before the journalist’s arrest, the police have no real grounds for claming that it had inflamed communal passions. Instead, it is obviously the complainant who is seeking to stoke the fires. It seems baffling that the police would arrest the reporter, instead of the complainant. Considering that the police have in the past failed to act on complaints against hate speeches by such figures as Bal Thackeray, the alacrity with which they arrested Ms Iyer is perplexing.

This is further evidence the Maharashtra government’s willingness to cave in to the demands of fundamentalists, a sentiment that it demonstrated earlier in February by issuing a non-bailable warrant against the editor of the Mumbai Mirror under the same section of the IPC, for printing a photo of an allegedly offensive tattoo. The editor had to obtain anticipatory bail to avoid arrest. In January, the Maharashtra government banned the translation by American academic James Laine of a praise poem, “The Epic of Shivaji”.

Episodes like this greatly compromise our ability to effectively function as journalists, and must be countered with strong condemnation.

Yours faithfully,
Naresh Fernandes
Comments:
This is the most disgusting thing I have ever heard. This corporator needs to be taught about the number of 'Mustafas' who are in jail for various crimes. Has this moron ever asked for their heads for denigrating their spiritual head? Will someone please give me the name of this corporator, so that we can tell him how and where he can get off?
 
Interesting....I just commented on this issue but a different angle ;)
 
I shudder at the alacrity of the situation plaguing the country. Could it be that the religious communities are getting desirious of their share of limelight? Editors I think will have to go on high-lert to avoid 'flaring up communal passions'. Prophet would have been weeping has he seen the existing interpretations of his ideologies by his own people.
 
The big question is what is the Times of India and its team of reporters doing about it. Shouldn't the paper and its writers be taking an initiative in fighting this? It would seem that Times prefers to sit quiet, bury its head, pretend it never happenend and carry on with business as usual.
 
The big question is what is the Times of India and its team of reporters doing about it. Shouldn't the paper and its writers be taking an initiative in fighting this? It would seem that Times prefers to sit quiet, bury its head, pretend it never happenend and carry on with business as usual.
 
Good News....

Now Times of India and its journalists must be realising how it feels like getting arrested with old and sick elders at midnight.

Hope, they get some more dose.

-Save Indian Family team
 
This was an interesting blog. And with so many team members, why don't we some more posts, and more frequently? We the people want more of we, the media.
 
I am going to watch this blog more closely.
First off the TOI writes utter nonsense and the entire management should be arrested for polluting people's minds with Page 3 drivel.
Their reporters don't know the basics of journalism.
A dog's name has become a topic of discussion.
I would put the journalist in question behind bars for have a sub-zero IQ.
Maybe Mr Naresh Fernandes should take some time out and walk down the streets of Patna.
 
I would put the journalist in question behind bars for have a sub-zero IQ.

Should read as:

I would put the journalist in question behind bars for *having* a sub-zero IQ.

Sorry I got bitten by the TOI typo bug.
 
best
 
besr
 
best
 
best
 
http://www.onlinedating.net.in/
 
http://www.moviespoint.org\
 
http://www.moviespoint.org\
 
ejaculating dong ejaculating dong
cock and balls cock and balls
jelly cock jelly cock
pleasureskin cock pleasureskin cock
cyberskin cock cyberskin cock
black cyberskin cock black cyberskin cock
realistic cyberskin cock realistic cyberskin cock
blow up sex dolls blow up sex dolls
bondage toys bondage toys
 
CHECK THIS UNIQUE SITE ALSO
www.nodahej.com Matrimonial Site is the worlds only Matrimonial Site for peoples who don't want to take and give dowries for their marriages.its total free site.Add your Free Matrimonial Profile Now.
http://nodahej.com
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

Recent Posts
More speculation about blogging and MSM
Dear TR Vivek,
Citizen journalism + a view from a skeptic
re-re-repeat funnies in Express, Delhi
The DNA of sting ops
Heart of Darkness
Bad Mid-Day?
The Hindu gets 'inspired'
Will The Real Author Please Stand Up?
Mistake? Yes, ok. Apology? No

Media Watchers
The Hoot
The War for News
newswatch.in
Spindian Express
editindia
CSF II

And also
Reporters Without Borders
Bloggers Without Borders

Archives
October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006


Powered by Blogger